While I understand that today is National Grilled Cheese Day, and am thrilled to see such a holiday exist, I find myself in a bit of a quandary. What exactly is a grilled cheese sandwich and when does a grilled cheese become a regular sandwich with melted cheese? Or a panini? It seems as if the line is a blurry one. There needs to be some sort of boundary; clear and distinct.
For example, I saw a post earlier with a picture of what appeared to be a normal sandwich with meat, cheese, vegetables and condiments. It looked good, don’t get me wrong, but it was labeled as a grilled cheese. Why? Because there was a slice of melted cheese (maybe swiss, I couldn’t quite tell)?
I have always been under the impression that a true grilled cheese sandwich is bread and cheese with maybe one or two other toppings. Small ones. The cheese should be the star. And the stage should not be crowded with stacks of meat and piles of lettuce. Let the cheese work its magic. Be creative, too. There are several types of cheese for a reason. Cheddar. American. Provolone. Brie. Manchego. Havarti and the list goes on.
Mix cheeses, blends of cheeses and even switch it up with different bread options. But, and let me be very clear about this because nobody else is, once you add more than three other items it becomes something else. Something we call a sandwich.
So…
Two slices of bread + a melted blend of three cheeses (Mahon, Manchego and Idiazabal) + slow-roasted tomatoes = a grilled cheese sandwich.
Why? Because the cheese shines and the tomatoes only enhance (not dominate) the flavors.
But…
Two slices of bread + a slice of melted American cheese + roast beef + grilled onions + lettuce + BBQ sauce = a sandwich. A delicious sandwich, but not a grilled cheese.
Why? I’ll let you figure that one out.
Good luck in your sandwich endeavors!